kiss the ground fact checking

Compost your food scraps. It carries pleasant stuff. Its filled with intelligent people who refuse to shy away from the impending climate cataclysm and have instead dedicated themselves to the daily work of facing itas farmers, educators, scientists, and yes, even as politicians. By partnering with Kiss the Ground, youre making a difference in the world and demonstrating that you are committed to supporting a regenerative future. A major strategy deployed in the documentary is offering two distinct choices for where consumers should source their food: conventional chemical-filled monocrops, or lush open fields of regenerative agriculture. This website uses third party cookies to improve your experience with your consent. Use your local food waste recycling system, and if they dont have one, write to your local council to ask for a food waste collection system. BOOM found that the viral video has been cropped from a longer conversation during a press conference where Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy mentioned a hypothetical scenario of Ukraine losing the war and Russia invading other NATO countries including the Baltic states in Eastern Europe which would force the US to get involved and send troops. Overlaying it, a swirling heat map of global atmospheric carbon, changing from dark red to cool blue over the course of a year. Archuleta describes the soil conservation problem as an education problem. All of these issues and more can be addressed, at least partially, by regenerative ag. "We should be thriving, the planet booming with life and abundance and the healthiest generation walking the earth. We told him that you need to leave the audience with hope, which I believe he did. One of my favorite elements of the documentary is the perspective that Earth has always been managing and sequestering carbon we just need to mimic that. I enjoyed Woody Harrelson as a narrator; he felt genuine. So the white papers cited dont even really know what HPG/AMP is or how it works. Here are five things I learned from Kiss the Ground. . And when it comes to the Savory Institute and Savorys claims Dr Garnett states that they are generally anecdotal, based on surveys and testimonies rather than on-site measurements. It does include grazing planning and management, but also many other things. Do you ever think about where your food comes from. doi:10.1093/jas/skx060 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jas/skx060, Stanley, P. L., Rowntree, J. E., Beede, D. K., DeLonge, M. S., & Hamm, M. W. (2018). Kris: No, but I am working on creating a virtual party with friends and family as we are scattered throughout the U.S. Ray: I will have a few people over. This seems like pretty important information that was left off the table. The filmmakers were able to discuss organic and regenerative agriculture, livestock production and veganism, and climate change in a manner that made no individuals or groups either heroes or villains but rather made the soil the hero which is the appropriate focus in my opinion. Rumi. Required fields are marked *. Future of Food: Journal on Food, Agriculture & Society, 4(3), 8. star wars fanfiction terran alliance; when a girl says i'll keep that in mind; hillsborough disaster who was to blame; how to get into stanford with a low gpa Its absolutely good to love the earth and want to save the soil. Lots of problems with Poores paper as well which didnt account for soil carbon or regenerative systems in any of its meta-analysis of averaged LCAs. While, there were very subtle hints that people would have only caught if paying very close attention, it was not made overtly clear by the documentary that the proposed solutions means transitioning the world to plant-rich diets. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Tilling loosens the soil, disturbing microorganisms that live within it, drying it out so. But here too Garnett doesnt understand the science. Also that we can fix this and the fix is quite simple. Understanding Ag is an equal opportunity provider and employer. There is one hyperlink in error. But efforts have been made to restore the soils since 1994. FACT-CHECK. Our modern farming methods are not concerned with soil longevity or quality and are significantly to blame for the destruction of the soils. reduce the burden of chronic disease in our communities, https://lachefnet.wordpress.com/2018/03/25/its-the-soil-biology-stupid/, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.agsy.2018.02.003, http://www.jswconline.org/content/71/2/156.abstract, https://asu.pure.elsevier.com/en/publications/potential-mitigation-of-midwest-grass-finished-beef-production-em, http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2011.03.009, https://blog.whiteoakpastures.com/hubfs/WOP-LCA-Quantis-2019.pdf. The basic premise of Kiss the Ground is that the destruction of soil is contributing to the severity and intensity of climate change. This is where a report written by Dr. Tara Garnett for the University of Oxford becomes very interesting a report titleGrazed and Confusedthat I have written about beforehere. Shop organic where you can. Garnetts FCRN self published paper basically just repeated Norborgs paper verbatim. No big deal. In short:- If you act with maturity and consideration for other users, you should Sign up for the latest courses, learning resources, news and events. Personally, I thought this was one of the better Netflix documentaries, mainly because, whilst theres a lot of negatives about where the world is heading, the overall message is one of hope. Parents need to know that Kiss the Ground is a 2020 documentary that addresses our current soil erosion crisis throughout the planet and the benefits of practicing "regenerative agriculture." Narrated by Woody Harrelson, the documentary features extensive interviews with farmers, scientists, activists, celebrities, and regular people as they help to create awareness of regenerative . Put simply, there are no healthy humans without a healthy planet. In many ways, this stands to do more harm than good. Learn how your comment data is processed. Before we get into a few major claims made inKiss the Groundthat are directly at odds with scientific knowledge, I want to preface this entry by saying that I wholeheartedly supportregenerative agricultureas a goal and think the documentary did a great job bringing light to the detrimental impact that intensive animal agriculture is having on our planet. Often, our best solutions arent actually that innovative; they simply mimic natural processes and what the Earth already does. Something went wrong. Get our weekly editors newsletter & special offers delivered right to your inbox! Firstly, just so we are clear, the majority of the worlds mono-crops are fed to livestock. You can see all of thisherefor yourself. Having gone from being a vegetable hating, stressed out and sick corporate mum who felt constant guilt for not feeding her family properly and not doing enough for the planet to a healthy, veggie loving and eco-minded mother with much less stress, she's been where you are and can definitely help you overcome your barriers! Although I would have liked more with real life farmers and ranchers, it is hard to put together a documentary that will appeal across the spectrum from rural to urban communities, young and old, and everyday people to activists. We need to spread the word to drive this important movement forwards! Enterprise, AL 36330. I do feel bad for the farmers trapped in the cycle though. Also, I must confess that I did not fully understand the implications of a film crew following me all over the country. I honestly thought it would stand on its own. Healthy soils can store more carbon than all the trees combined! Kiss the Ground has been active in this space for a while and is a California-based 501(c)(3) environmental non-profit telling a new story about our ability to regenerate land and reverse climate change by building back healthy soil. Regardless of the above claims being scientifically supported or not (well come to that) if one is to advocate for a shift to holistic grazing this will inevitably result in a dramatic reduction in global meat supply. In March and April, he says, farmers are tilling. When those are plants that we eat, healthy soil is crucial. I dont know a single holistic management practitioner that advocates cutting down forests to grow more cattle. Autor de l'entrada Per ; Data de l'entrada calexico west port of entry hours; 12 month libor rate 2021 a kiss the ground fact checking a kiss the ground fact checking With that said, any time a new study, book, documentary, or other media publication is published, I read or watch with great interest. Monocropping further exacerbates the issue, as the same crop is grown year on year, for miles in the case of US farms, microbial diversity cannot increase. Whilst maintaining a large veg bed to feed the whole family takes up a lot of space and requires time, there are many crops that require very little maintenance or space, and actually like growing in your flower beds amongst the flowers! But as crops grow month by month, drawing down atmospheric carbon, the red is gradually replaced by greens and then by blues, until the map is recognizable once again as the pale blue dot we call home. Xu, S. (2016). I wanted the filmmakers to first understandto let the soil speak and to let nature teach us. Simple reducing emission does nothing to decrease the greenhouse gases that are already in our atmosphere. Consumers need to do their part by supporting pastured proteins. Talking about the importance of beingbetter stewards of our land, and why we must do a better job at protecting our natural resources and ecosystems, is absolutely crucial if our species is to not just thrive on Planet Earth, but survive. Copyright 2021 Understanding Ag, LLC | Website by RVT Solutions. Kiss the Ground is a 501 (c)(3) Nonprofit Find farms local to you that are farming in a regenerative way and support them by buying your produce from there. A degenerative system that decimates life in our soil, releases immense amounts of greenhouse gas emissions into our atmosphere, pollutes our waterways, and disrupts the biodiversity and biology on our land and in our oceans. This review revealed some all to common perceptions about holistic management, a decision making framework, which can be applied to grazing as well as other management situations. The lazy author of this review makes the same mistaken claim. This is how the natural carbon cycle should work. Finally, the elephant / cow in the room (not sure which is more fitting) duringKiss the Ground is how are we going to produce enough meat using holistic grazing to meet current demands? Let me show you how , Get my FREE guide, and receive eco-friendly eating tips, recipes and motivation. Sounds pretty ambitious to champion this form of animal agriculture as a climate solution without strong empirical evidence? Regenerative agriculture is an important part of the solution when it comes to climate change. This is bio sequestration using plants to capture and store carbon. The movie stars Woody Harrelson, David Arquette, Gisele Bundchen, Jason Mraz (and others) and three newly minted stars you may know personally: Understanding Ags Ray Archuleta, Gabe Brown and Kris Nichols, Ph.D. Those of us who have been in the regenerative ag arena for some time, already know these three as soil health super-stars, but now a wider, world-wide audience will benefit from their experience, insight and wisdom, too. 114k square miles regenerated! Its not too long, but youll learn a lot from it. The movie didn't even include an indictment of current US politics or President Trump, which is notable by its absence considering the film was released so close to election time. If you have found your way to this article, I can only assume that we have something in common: both of us want to see a better world where humans and all life on earth is thriving. The elephant in the room during the documentary is that they completely failed to mention that a significant amount of the land dedicated to animal agriculture across the world (not all but certainly a lot) needs to be restored to forests (the number one driver of deforestation is animal agriculture) to get anywhere close to meeting our climate goals. There seems to be an incredibly fine line between grazing just enough and overgrazing, which speaks to potentially whycrediblepeer-reviewed science has to date, failed to produce results that come close to what Alan Savory claims. These are more expensive, so if you can only afford to go organic with some, choose the Dirty dozen so that you get the health benefits of avoiding all the chemicals too The Dirty Dozen organic.org. However, this was taken from a United Nations speech, which leading soil scientists say isabsolutely not supported by science. In fact, if we look at the solutions outlined in theDrawdown Reportand their potential to draw down carbon from our atmosphere, shifting to a diet that favours calories from plants is twice as powerful compared to shifting to silvopasture and four times as powerful compared as shifting to managed grazing two forms of regenerative agriculture that involve livestock. The long term prognosis for our survival with business as usual is very, very poor . In other words, his claims cannot be supported by data, replicated by others and he doesnt believe in science. ), Pollinator garden/market flowers at Copper Cricket Farm. Tilling and chemical agricultural methods have disrupted this cycle and increased the rate of carbon release. If we adopt regenerative farming practices, we can reverse carbon release into the atmosphere and stabilise the climate, and it wont take long! have no problems. What the writers ignored is that it was SCIENCE that led to that preferred plan of action. In COP21 in Paris, 2015. Unless we save our soils, we have 60 harvests left before global starvation. IMPRESS, 16-18 New Brige Street, London, EC4V 6AG. Looking for a way to kill the quarantine boredom? Gabe: HaHa! Does the movie miss the mark in any way, or would you have liked to have seen particulartopics covered that were not? And so, with these words, Harrelson immediately draws us into "Kiss the Ground," a documentary focusing on growing our food in a way that builds and protects our precious soil and also draws back into the ground the carbon dioxide that is causing climate change. We already use 3-4 times more fertiliser for each bushel of grain than in the 60s. Scientists work hard to do science, yet despite thousand of papers produced by human nutrition scientists, the diet health of US occupants is at its worst level ever. Remember that the decision to depopulate the elephants when Savory was with the game department was a result of the current science among wildlife researchers. By taking carbon dioxide from the air, and sending it down to soil microbes in exchange for nutrients, plants can not only remove carbon from the atmosphere, but store carbon in the soils. As an employee of the Natural Resources Conservation Service, he travels around the country educating farmers on more sustainable farming practices. Theres also a lot of new recent PEER REVIEWED soil science that demonstrates this. Ganrett also doesnt have a clue how tropospheric hydroxyl oxidation works. No spam, we promise just our best articles. Directors Joshua Tickell Rebecca Harrell Tickell Writers Johnny O'Hara Joshua Tickell Rebecca Harrell Tickell Stars If not, heres what you can do to join the regenerative farming movement, or at least help make things better . I started trying to teach about soil health with my little plastic jars and myco-workers at the tech center would often laugh and make fun of me. Hi! Livestock and Land Use: How Are We Feeding The Planet? If we restore all the degraded land, we can return the earth to paradise, making room for biodiversity and feeding the worlds population (with lowered animal protein consumption). So sadly neither does the author of this review. what happens if you get a violation on interlock. That sounds catastrophic. The filmmakers additionally say "Kiss the Ground" has earned the attention of scientists, farmers and activists alike, crossing boundaries in terms of a highly politicized issue and even being . This is because there is a legacy load of carbon in the atmosphere an amount of carbon dioxide that will persist for decades, if not centuries. Celebrity activists, including Ian Somerhalder and Patricia Arquette, drop by to promote a suite of carbon-capture climate change solutions theyre personally involved in, from diversified permaculture to compost toilets. The next thing I want to address, and perhaps the most important take-home message here, is the science underpinning holistic grazing is flaky at best. shabu shabu groupon. GHG Mitigation Potential of Different Grazing Strategies in the United States Southern Great Plains. 70% of US cropland grows only corn, soy and hay, and this is mainly to feed livestock (99%!). Kris: We are facing a catastrophic cascade in Earths ecosystems impacting human health and the global economy which fundamentally rests in pressures stemming from changes in the economic and ecological agricultural landscape due to climate change and escalating worldwide competition for natural resources and commodities, including petroleum, natural gas, grains,oilseeds, and proteins. Watching attentively, a classroom full of farmers. We recently caught up with @mcgrathfamilyfarm. Using livestock is thought to make this process 7 times faster! The first clue is when the documentary makes mention of the natural history of Bison roaming the United States. Many of the pesticides and fertilisers have been derived from poison gases used in warfare (chemical warfare and poison used in gas chambers). Gabe: That each and every person needs to step up and make a differencethat they can make a difference by purchasing from farmers and ranchers who practice regenerative ag. Ive listed these below in short, and then we will go through each together looking at the claims made and where the science lies: (These have also been covered in detail with Environmental Researcher Nicholas Carter (co-author of this article) in episode 104 and 111 on thePlant Proof podcast). Im sure we can all agree that factory farming is a blight on humanity, and there is far too much mono-cropping, but assuming that its either this intensive form of animal agriculture or holistic grazing, is not accurate. I dont understand how they didnt emphasize that you still have to eat a plant rich diet if you want everyone in the world to eat pasture raised animals Theres only so much to land and hence animals you can raise. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. Kris:The time and effort that the team put into the interviews and edits as well as probably debating and refining the perspective the film takes should be commended. But the agreement is that all of the richest grasslands in the world have large grazing animals. Kiss the Groundgave the microphone to Ranchers Alan Savory and Gabe Brown, but we didnt hear about any legitimate science testing out whether the claims they were making truly hold up? There are a number of others as well as many more in the pipeline. Our mission stands strong: to awaken people to the possibilities of regeneration and inspire participation in the regenerative movement. As Hannah Ritchie, Phd (Geosciences) puts it: Whether you buy it from the farmer next door or from far away, it is not the location that makes the carbon footprint of your dinner large, but the fact that it is beef.. San Francisco have an amazing system, and are the most sustainable city in the US! By Heres my critique of that paper: https://lachefnet.wordpress.com/2018/03/25/its-the-soil-biology-stupid/ This paper includes a number of these soil science papers. This sounds like something else that he would likely regret in the near future. If he is the only one that can achieve the carbon sequestration that he claims, I fail to see how thats a hopeful solution. The problem is, the lay viewer who is not across the science, and blinded by the message of hope, is likely to confuse the role of cows in holistic grazing with instruction that we should continue eating meat at current rates (as long as its grass-fed) and perhaps even double down on our meat consumption. Despite all of this, my fear is that many will be left with a complete misunderstanding of where environmental science truly lies. We started ploughing/tilling because it was easier for us to upscale. Many countries signed, including the UK, but not the US, China or India, the biggest agricultural and CO2 producers. Im Sarah, a Sustainable Nutrition and Behaviour Change Coach, and Im here to help if youre done with feeling guilty about doing too little to reduce your environmental impact and feed yourself healthy foods. For millions of years the world has self-healed and self-balanced. are needed to help heal the earth. I just heard of the movie and wanted to find out a little more about it until I get time to watch it. Regenerated healthy soil greatly increases the carrying capacity of land, so the amount of land needed for regen grazing isnt an issue. Rising animal production and consumption, whatever the farming system and animal type, is causing damaging greenhouse gas release and contributing to changes in land use. But I wish people with platforms like documentary films or acting stardom would start framing issues with words that suggest physical work, like "repair" or fix or even "care for/take care of" (i.e. Instagram @maggie.eileen.art). Upcoming Kiss the Ground Movie Features Three Understanding Ag Experts, Questions and Answers with Our In-House Stars. Whats glaringly clear from Hawkens report is that when it comes to our food and greenhouse gas emissions, thetwo areas we can make the biggest impactare reducing food waste (number one solution)and moving to a plant-rich diet (number three solution). This process of soil destruction is detrimental to agriculture. Bundchen and Brady point to the health of the soil as directly influencing the health of the plants we eat and our health as well. Ray: That a large audience will come away with a basic awareness about the transformative power of our living and life-giving soil. Animals grazing is a part of the carbon cycle, and part of every healthy ecosystem in wild. Rousing speeches have their place in communicating the gravity of the situation to the public, funders, and policymakers, but its not a framing that suggests concrete action, or even a plan. Half are experts working in their respective fields, and the rest are celebrity activists for whom regenerative agriculture and climate change is more or less a cause. (Though theyre still good ideas.). In fact, the documentary claims that greenhouse gases are sequestered (stored/drawn down) in grazing herds, due to the generation of healthy soils, but released in feed lots where the animals are not a part of the natural cycle. It turned out to be more involved than I imagined. And as the documentary states, shifting us from climate warming to climate cooling. This is a review Im very familiar with having read through it front to back a handful of times. He's a lover of people and of life. This form of regenerative agriculture is by no means the silver bullet that its so often portrayed to be and is certainly not what theworlds leading climate scientistsare most excited by. Industrial agriculture (left) causes desertification through tilling and synthetic pesticides and fertilizers. Farmers need to make profits but we need to be transparent here and lay down all solutions on the table to have an open discussion. He also heard about the NRCS soil health effort and my role in encouraging the agency to bring more resources to support the regenerative ag movement. Its the misbalance of carbon that is the issue. Unfortunately, there are still very few about, especially in the UK. Ray: As they say, He who has the gold makes the rules, so there was a lot of pressure to have Josh, the director, slant this movie towards veganism, messaging cows are bad, eat less meat, carbon footprint, and organic farming will save the world, kind of stuff. Over the years, tilling causes the soil to dirt, leaving it vulnerable to erosion and desertification. . Anecdote and expert opinion or theories are at the bottom of the evidence hierarchy, and its not until we see the findings from higher levels of science, reproduced on scale, that we can begin to have confidence in what we are observing. Take the Inflammation quiz - what's your level? Water and carbon escape into the atmosphere in enormous plumes blanketing the entire northern hemisphereshown onscreen as ominous swirls of red. It really feels like he cares. The good news is that soils can recover fast if they are allowed to and managed correctly. Your email address will not be published. I was also pleased the documentary shone a light on food waste and composting these are two things that many of us can introduce into our daily lives with minimal barriers to entry. Plus FCRNs paper simply ignored the existing peer reviewed science with its claim that no such science exists. BookstoreBook submissionsNewsNewsletter signupRecipesGardening, Our storyGet involvedJobs/FellowshipPartnersContact usPrivacy Shipping & return policy. One of the first characters introduced in Kiss the Ground is Ray Archuleta, a conservation agronomist. Regenerative agriculture is a more resilient system based on principles of soil health and biodiversity that integrates multiple crops, cover crops, and livestock animals. Seven years in the making, the movies thesis proposes that by regenerating the worlds soils, humans can rapidly stabilize Earths climate, restore lost ecosystems and create abundant food supplies. Byck, P. (2016). "All farmable soil could be gone in 60 years. I promise not to sell your information, and if you don't like what I send, you can easily unsubscribe at any point. Data from almost40,000 farms, and 119 countries, clearly shows us that a plant-based diet results in less greenhouse gas emissions, less pollution, less ocean acidification, and uses less water and land land which we can therefore free up and convert to forests to rapidly sequester carbon from our atmosphere. Cited as the worst man made environmental disaster in history, by the end of 1934 about 200 million acres of croplands had been permanently damaged. We have now decoupled these so farmers are either crop or livestock, and each are done on an intensive scale, with no natural cycles in place. Garnett, Poore and their ilk just do key word searches on computer screens and average parsed pre-existing data in their papers. If cattle are allowed to roam and graze, they contribute to carbon sequestration the process by which plants take carbon dioxide from the atmosphere and store it in the soil. After the country decided to increase yields and started intensively farming and tilling the fertile midwestern plains, leaving the soil bare for large periods of time. Heres below are just a handful of recent PEER REVIEWED papers supporting HPG. HaHa! Fund charities that are helping people to compost their poo in toilets in the third world. I doubt this will require an agent or a move haha! (Source: Kiss the Ground). Their mob grazing action and the impact of their hooves is important. And this isnt just my own speculation. Other soil-based carbon capture solutions like composting are crucial to regenerative agriculture. So ifKiss the Groundhad taken a more evidence-based approach and included dietary recommendations what would it have looked like? Less meat to go around and significantly higher prices per unit. The film uses creative graphics and visuals, along with striking NASA and NOAA footage, and illustrates how, by drawing down atmospheric carbon many of humankinds most pressing climate and environmental problems can be solved. Suppose you don't have enough time to read, then watch the KISS the GROUND MOVIE (streaming on Netflix) hosted by Woody Harrelson and directed by Joshua Tickell and Rebecca Harrell Tickell. A Feb. 27, 2023, video of U.S. President Joe Biden purportedly shows him announcing a new national draft, in which 20-year-olds would be conscripted into military service on account of a growing . The French Minister for agriculture proposed a 4 in 1000 plan, to increase the organic content of our soils by 0.4% per year. Kiss the Ground. Why not let the viewer know what theworlds leading climate scientists have to say about diet? You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates. . Your email address will not be published. Theres nothing Netflix and chillabout that. We should harness the regenerative power of the earth and its processes. Every year 40m people are displaced as their farmlands become desert. berger 215 hybrid 300 win mag. Get exclusive content in your inbox each Monday. Many of them are based on anecdotal evidence and experience. That was good enough for me. However, there is a slight problem with the way they presented the information from the Drawdown report. Filmmakers Josh Tickell and Rebecca Tickell wound up spending seven years making their latest doc, "Kiss the Ground," and all along the way they worried that by the end of the process there .

Celtic Park View From My Seat, Happy Valley Middle School Death, Is Monroe Community Hospital Haunted, Jesse Lafser And Brittany Howard Wedding, Articles K